More thoughts on books
Fri, Jul. 25th, 2003 08:34 pmKushner, Ellen - Thomas the Rhymer
I finished Kushner's Thomas the Rhymer and liked it much better the second time round. It's written in four parts, each part first-person POV of a person close to Thomas or Thomas himself. I don't actually have that much to say about it, hrm. I liked the differences between Thomas before his seven years in elfhame and after, I especially liked his relationship with Gavin and Meg, an old couple he befriends before he leaves. I also love the section when he's in fairy, the language, the description, the riddle the Hunter puts him to. And I loved having him adjust to his gift of truth and to the world in general when he comes back. However, I thought his reconciliation with Elspeth would have lasted longer, and I didn't like her section of the book as much. It just felt a little off to me, as though these characters I had known had changed much too quickly from the dynamics that I had been used to for the most part of the book.
-
keilexandra's review
Schone, Robin - Awaken, My Love
Also finished Robin Schone's Awaken, My Love, and I'm definitely not picking this author up again! Ugh. I'm all for historical accuracy, and I think historical romances too often pretty up the past. Schone seems determined to not do this, describing a modern-day woman's reaction to not bathing enough, to chamber pots and dirty clothes and greasy hair. And it's nice to have that instead of nostalgia, but then, when an author is going to put that level of realism in, I don't want to read about weeping male members and all that purple prose! Plus, her hero is apparently well versed in the Kama Sutra or something like it. And it might just be me, but having the emphasis on personal hygiene in the nineteenth century juxtaposed with exotic Indian terms for vagina and the like really didn't work. Plus, the hero sucked. He was boring and chauvanistic and all those other bad alpha male stereotypes without even being sexy. I didn't like Elaine much either, and I didn't really find her position of being the sex-deprived housewife that realistic. She's from modern times, supposedly, yet apparently her husband doesn't have sex with her, thinks she's insane for having sex manuals and the like. I mean, I'm sure those people exist, but it just seemed too different from my life to be "modern." And then of course, the villain had to be female. This is one of my huge pet peeves. Not that I hate female villains, but I really hate them in romance novels, where they're petty and jealous and cruel because *gasp* they've lost their man's affection and must get it back! Of course not having a man in our lives makes all females vicious bitches who, instead of blaming the guy, go postal on the other woman. Ugh. Then Schone had the grand revelation that the female villain was afraid of sex and half insane because she was sexually abused by her uncle! And instead of having sympathy for the poor girl, she just was the villain. The hero of course showed no remorse that he had forced her to have sex, despite her previous history of abuse, and I don't think we were supposed to feel sorry for her at all. It just felt like a very misogynistic book. Ick. I hate that, the attitude that girls are raped because they are somehow bad people.
Stargate SG-1
Still blazing through Stargate! I never have much to say about Stargate because I don't really analyze it like Buffy. I just watch and enjoy. And I don't even really care that there's not that much character continuity between episodes (e.g. Sam finds her father has cancer, next episode, doesn't mention it) because I just love watching the team interact with each other. I'm so glad Sam's not this minor, token female who just stands by and watches the big men do things. Instead, she's always in the thick of things, always thinking of solutions for the team. And ok, she's a little Giles-like in her exposition function, but we never see a Sam who is not capable. I love her; she's awesome. And Jack is always snarky and funny and quirky. I love his reaction to all the Carterisms and to Daniel's excited cultural explanations. I love Teal'c and his little eyebrow quirks. Back to watching more now!
I finished Kushner's Thomas the Rhymer and liked it much better the second time round. It's written in four parts, each part first-person POV of a person close to Thomas or Thomas himself. I don't actually have that much to say about it, hrm. I liked the differences between Thomas before his seven years in elfhame and after, I especially liked his relationship with Gavin and Meg, an old couple he befriends before he leaves. I also love the section when he's in fairy, the language, the description, the riddle the Hunter puts him to. And I loved having him adjust to his gift of truth and to the world in general when he comes back. However, I thought his reconciliation with Elspeth would have lasted longer, and I didn't like her section of the book as much. It just felt a little off to me, as though these characters I had known had changed much too quickly from the dynamics that I had been used to for the most part of the book.
-
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Schone, Robin - Awaken, My Love
Also finished Robin Schone's Awaken, My Love, and I'm definitely not picking this author up again! Ugh. I'm all for historical accuracy, and I think historical romances too often pretty up the past. Schone seems determined to not do this, describing a modern-day woman's reaction to not bathing enough, to chamber pots and dirty clothes and greasy hair. And it's nice to have that instead of nostalgia, but then, when an author is going to put that level of realism in, I don't want to read about weeping male members and all that purple prose! Plus, her hero is apparently well versed in the Kama Sutra or something like it. And it might just be me, but having the emphasis on personal hygiene in the nineteenth century juxtaposed with exotic Indian terms for vagina and the like really didn't work. Plus, the hero sucked. He was boring and chauvanistic and all those other bad alpha male stereotypes without even being sexy. I didn't like Elaine much either, and I didn't really find her position of being the sex-deprived housewife that realistic. She's from modern times, supposedly, yet apparently her husband doesn't have sex with her, thinks she's insane for having sex manuals and the like. I mean, I'm sure those people exist, but it just seemed too different from my life to be "modern." And then of course, the villain had to be female. This is one of my huge pet peeves. Not that I hate female villains, but I really hate them in romance novels, where they're petty and jealous and cruel because *gasp* they've lost their man's affection and must get it back! Of course not having a man in our lives makes all females vicious bitches who, instead of blaming the guy, go postal on the other woman. Ugh. Then Schone had the grand revelation that the female villain was afraid of sex and half insane because she was sexually abused by her uncle! And instead of having sympathy for the poor girl, she just was the villain. The hero of course showed no remorse that he had forced her to have sex, despite her previous history of abuse, and I don't think we were supposed to feel sorry for her at all. It just felt like a very misogynistic book. Ick. I hate that, the attitude that girls are raped because they are somehow bad people.
Stargate SG-1
Still blazing through Stargate! I never have much to say about Stargate because I don't really analyze it like Buffy. I just watch and enjoy. And I don't even really care that there's not that much character continuity between episodes (e.g. Sam finds her father has cancer, next episode, doesn't mention it) because I just love watching the team interact with each other. I'm so glad Sam's not this minor, token female who just stands by and watches the big men do things. Instead, she's always in the thick of things, always thinking of solutions for the team. And ok, she's a little Giles-like in her exposition function, but we never see a Sam who is not capable. I love her; she's awesome. And Jack is always snarky and funny and quirky. I love his reaction to all the Carterisms and to Daniel's excited cultural explanations. I love Teal'c and his little eyebrow quirks. Back to watching more now!