Wu, Frank H. - Yellow: Race in America Beyond Black and White
Sat, Oct. 7th, 2006 06:30 pmI keep meaning to blog this book, because I really liked it. More importantly, it, along with Tatum's book, gave me a good framework to think about race in America. Bonus points for not forgetting that there are more than two races here. It's rather self-serving, but I was glad that Wu concentrated on Asian-Americans.
He goes into the standard "racism = prejudice + power" and explains how it's an institutional thing in the beginning, and then he moves on to arguments specific to Asian-Americans. Namely: why do Asians complain about racism, what with the whole "model minority" thing and all? I wanted to hug Wu for giving such a cogent explanation on how the model-minority myth is a double-edged sword, at best, and I wanted to hug him even more when he discussed how it impacted not just Asian-white relations in America, but also Asian relations with other minorities and how it set minorities off against each other.
He addresses issues such as Asians living in Asia vs. Asian-Americans, affirmative action, the history of racism against Asian-Americans in America, and multi-racial people. I did, however, want to fault him for concentrating more on East Asians than all Asians, though he does write about non-East-Asians as well and how they fit into the dynamic and how they often get left behind in "Asian"-American coalitions.
I didn't always follow his arguments, particularly when he reached the bit on racial profiling, but in general, Wu is compassionate, even though you can tell how angry he is about the state of affairs.
I'm not adequately expressing just how excited I was while I was reading this. There were so many times I wanted to jump up and say, "Yes! Yes, that's it!" and it was so helpful to read this during IBARW. Wu also notes that he is a professional Asian-American; he hates that it is necessary for someone like him, and he dislikes having to be a spokesperson, but he also sees the necessity of it. So part of my admiration for his work was tinged with regret that it was still needed. But mostly, I admire that he can write about this topic at all, and I'm even more impressed with his call for coalitions, not just within the Asian-American community (and to have that community welcome all Asians and not focus solely on East Asians), but also among all people of color and white people as well.
Links:
-
minnow1212's review
He goes into the standard "racism = prejudice + power" and explains how it's an institutional thing in the beginning, and then he moves on to arguments specific to Asian-Americans. Namely: why do Asians complain about racism, what with the whole "model minority" thing and all? I wanted to hug Wu for giving such a cogent explanation on how the model-minority myth is a double-edged sword, at best, and I wanted to hug him even more when he discussed how it impacted not just Asian-white relations in America, but also Asian relations with other minorities and how it set minorities off against each other.
He addresses issues such as Asians living in Asia vs. Asian-Americans, affirmative action, the history of racism against Asian-Americans in America, and multi-racial people. I did, however, want to fault him for concentrating more on East Asians than all Asians, though he does write about non-East-Asians as well and how they fit into the dynamic and how they often get left behind in "Asian"-American coalitions.
I didn't always follow his arguments, particularly when he reached the bit on racial profiling, but in general, Wu is compassionate, even though you can tell how angry he is about the state of affairs.
I'm not adequately expressing just how excited I was while I was reading this. There were so many times I wanted to jump up and say, "Yes! Yes, that's it!" and it was so helpful to read this during IBARW. Wu also notes that he is a professional Asian-American; he hates that it is necessary for someone like him, and he dislikes having to be a spokesperson, but he also sees the necessity of it. So part of my admiration for his work was tinged with regret that it was still needed. But mostly, I admire that he can write about this topic at all, and I'm even more impressed with his call for coalitions, not just within the Asian-American community (and to have that community welcome all Asians and not focus solely on East Asians), but also among all people of color and white people as well.
Links:
-
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)