![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Yamamoto Naoki - Dance 'Till Tomorrow, vol. 01 (Eng. trans.)
Thu, Jun. 17th, 2004 11:55 pmFirst new manga I've read in quite some time -- it's kind of funny having several people on the reading list start reading manga (and meeting the girl in Hawaii who was very into it) after having sort of passed my glomming stage.
I picked it up because it was at the store and because one of the books had some sort of Editor's Choice thing on it. Must remember sometimes that trusting the summary on the back is a good thing. It seems to be a fairly typical shounen romance, ala Marmalade Boy and Tenchi Muyo and all those other ones. By fairly typical I mean the setup, in which a young, fairly normal, down-to-earth guy (sort of the male version of the gawky girl with glasses), Suekichi, is interested in a nice, good girl (in this case, the director of his theater troupe, I think), while being sexually tempted by a morally dubious, very open girl. At least, that was the set up in the first book. Granted, the next few could have changed the formula a bit, but from reading the backs, it didn't much seem like it, so I gave up. I don't know if there is a similar setup in non-manga fiction -- I can sort of see echoes of it in Robert Jordan (Rand has three girls chasing after him!) and in Elfstones of Shannara (Eretria and Amberle), and I'm sure others have it as well, but maybe not so obviously? But I think it's safe to say that it's a pretty well-established genre or sub-genre or trope or whatever you choose to call it in manga and in anime.
It's also a trope that annoys me, mostly because the girls are really stupid and fight each other constantly for the guy. And while I am generally all for women who are open about their sexuality, the type in these works tends to turn me off because they feel so gratuitous. You know, I wonder if this is how guys feel when they read romance novels. Good but boring guy vs. hot and slightly uncivilized stud is a pretty common formula (see: Sunfire romances). There's a lot of sex in this book, and it's fairly graphic. I was actually surprised at what was drawn at times, give the censorship laws in Japan. Maybe they've changed? I do remember that they aren't supposed to draw any sort of pubic hair or genitalia, but I distinctly remember seeing a penis or two. Maybe I am making it up. Generally, the attitude is very literal, so you see pretty much everything, except the girl looks like she's giving a blowjob to a cylindrical white space (and etc.).
Anyway, it wasn't really my thing. I think people who like Tenchi Muyo and Love Hina would enjoy it.
( On anime and manga in general )
I picked it up because it was at the store and because one of the books had some sort of Editor's Choice thing on it. Must remember sometimes that trusting the summary on the back is a good thing. It seems to be a fairly typical shounen romance, ala Marmalade Boy and Tenchi Muyo and all those other ones. By fairly typical I mean the setup, in which a young, fairly normal, down-to-earth guy (sort of the male version of the gawky girl with glasses), Suekichi, is interested in a nice, good girl (in this case, the director of his theater troupe, I think), while being sexually tempted by a morally dubious, very open girl. At least, that was the set up in the first book. Granted, the next few could have changed the formula a bit, but from reading the backs, it didn't much seem like it, so I gave up. I don't know if there is a similar setup in non-manga fiction -- I can sort of see echoes of it in Robert Jordan (Rand has three girls chasing after him!) and in Elfstones of Shannara (Eretria and Amberle), and I'm sure others have it as well, but maybe not so obviously? But I think it's safe to say that it's a pretty well-established genre or sub-genre or trope or whatever you choose to call it in manga and in anime.
It's also a trope that annoys me, mostly because the girls are really stupid and fight each other constantly for the guy. And while I am generally all for women who are open about their sexuality, the type in these works tends to turn me off because they feel so gratuitous. You know, I wonder if this is how guys feel when they read romance novels. Good but boring guy vs. hot and slightly uncivilized stud is a pretty common formula (see: Sunfire romances). There's a lot of sex in this book, and it's fairly graphic. I was actually surprised at what was drawn at times, give the censorship laws in Japan. Maybe they've changed? I do remember that they aren't supposed to draw any sort of pubic hair or genitalia, but I distinctly remember seeing a penis or two. Maybe I am making it up. Generally, the attitude is very literal, so you see pretty much everything, except the girl looks like she's giving a blowjob to a cylindrical white space (and etc.).
Anyway, it wasn't really my thing. I think people who like Tenchi Muyo and Love Hina would enjoy it.
( On anime and manga in general )