Kay, Guy Gavriel - Tigana

[oyceter]

First things: Wow! We got Saddam Hussein.

Suddenly, the world feels very different.

Catching up on books:

Recently read Richard Feynman's What Do You Care What Other People Think?, which was as fun as his earlier book.

Also recently reread Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay, which I think broke my heart a little. It always does this to me. And I always forget what happens in the end, so I'm perpetually surprised by what Dianora does. Spoilers ahead (a little for Fionavar Tapestry too):

There is just so much grief packed into the book -- for Tigana, for Staven, for missing brothers and sisters, for estranged parents and sons. And it sounds so trivial a punishment almost: the book is about the people of Tigana, a province of the Peninsula of the Palm, conquered for about twenty years or so by Brandin of Ygrath and Alberico of Barbadios, two tyrants from overseas battling for this piece of land. And Brandin's son was killed in Tigana, so he erased the name of the province so none but those who were born there or magicians could hear it. Such a little thing, and yet, such a blow. It reminds me of the stories of colonized countries or people who are not allowed to speak their own language, not allowed to teach it to their children. I know a generation in Taiwan grew up speaking Japanese because of the occupation, and I'm sure this happens almost everywhere that is conquered.

Like most of GGK's books, there are sacrifices and noble deeds, everything tinged with that sadness that Tokien brought to LotR, the sense of things passing, the bittersweetness in life and death. The story that always touches me most is that of Dianora and her ill-fated feelings for Brandin, and I always hope that somehow, they get to be reborn in Finavir/Fionavar. Speaking of which, that was one of the most painful things for me in the Fionavar Tapestry, that Diarmuid and Sharra wouldn't get that chance because they had already been born there.

I finally figured out one of the things that has always bothered me about the end of Tigana -- Dianora will be remembered only as Dianora di Certando. Rhun's story will not be remembered at all. And in this book in which memory is so strong and so potent, this seems wrong. These are two people whose true names will never be remembered, and as such, it is almost as though they did not do what they did, that their suffering meant nothing.

I love the last line of the book though.

I always have a hard time talking about these books that affect me so much, because the feelings they evoke are almost too large and too strong to adequately express in words. It's the sacrifices that hit me the hardest, Diarmuid in Fionavar, Dianora and Catriana and Sandre's here, like Buffy in the Gift and Angel in Home.

Links:
- inklings_lj's collected reviews (all spoilery)
- sophia_helix's review (spoilers)

Comments

Oh yea....

[writeonq.livejournal.com]

GGK ROCKS! I think he is one of the most underrated of today's writers. His work is so rich - in terms of research and both technical and emotional content! I don't find it surprising that he moves you so...

Re: Oh yea....

[oyceter]

I know! He's not as well-known as the other fantasy heavy weights, but he's so good! My favorites of his remain Tigana and the Fionavar Tapestry, because the ending of FT kills me every single time. Plus, Diarmuid.

[ebonbird.livejournal.com]

which I think broke my heart a little.

Tigana breaks my heart. Or at least, it walks on the healing places.. or the weaker ones. The loss is enormous... it cannot be contained by that world.

[oyceter]

Yes, that's it. It's not the pain -- it's the almost lingering bittersweet quality that's a little too real or too sharp to be contained.

[katie-m.livejournal.com]

Oh, Tigana. Tigana kills me. Just absolutely kills me. The moment when Brandin tells Dianora that he loves her? And then love not being enough to, how does he put it, bridge the chasms in her world? I cry every time.

And when Diarmuid dies, of course, in the Fionavar trilogy. It's not that I don't see the weaknesses in that trilogy, but man, I cry like a baby.

[oyceter]

Oh yes! The line about how they should have met in Finavir, ow ow ow. And I always think that she drowns in the ring ceremony for some reason, and am always surprised and heartbroken when she comes back, having lost her way but having Brandin too.

*nods* I definitely see the derivativeness/Tolkienness of the trilogy, but I actually like it better than Tolkien, heh. More girls. Plus, made me like the Guinevere story, which I've always hated. I think the first few times I reread it, I wandered around in a daze for a day or so, thinking that Diarmuid couldn't be dead.

[stakebait.livejournal.com]

I adore this book.

Tigana, let me memory of you be like a blade in my soul.

Because love is what it is, but it is not enough. Not here.

Hers was not a life meant to be made whole.

It honestly never hit me that the Fionavar Tapestry was meant to be the same world. I recognized the name, of course, but I just thought he was reusing some element of his own private mythology, or some element of actual mythology that I didn't recognize. I might have to reread them all again, now.

Mer

[oyceter]

Dianora's story hurts every time I read it.

I've seen mentions of Fionavar in I think every book he's written -- not sure about the Sailing to Sarantium series, haven't read it yet, but in the others, there's some small mention. Makes me happy ^_^.