oyceter: teruterubouzu default icon (Default)
[personal profile] oyceter
Initial random thoughts! (With spoilers for the comics arcs as well.)

I have to burble in here because CB was going on and on about how he did not like it that much and the plot holes and etc. and I was kind of just... hello I just want to go on about STEEEEEVVEEEEEE and NATASHAAAAAA and I do not really care about the plot!

I mean, bringing Hydra in basically always makes things kind of silly. On the other hand, I can see the bits and pieces of the comics they were putting in there and trying to stitch together, from Batroc (AHAHAHAHA sorry I still can't take him seriously. At least he didn't have the mustache?) to the secret agents of Hydra inside of SHIELD. Thank goodness this time it wasn't Sharon Carter being brainwashed.

To get it out of the way, other stuff I didn't like: how the movies keep alllmooooost getting into how SHIELD and SHIELD's methods really aren't the best way to operate, but then swerve away at the last minute by creating an even more evil organization and thus validating our heroes in the end. (Which makes me even more baffled by Agents of SHIELD, because it somehow manages to be more optimistic about SHIELD and SHIELD agents than the movies!) And they really could have done without the speechifying by Steve, but especially Natasha, because I just don't buy it from Natasha.

...also Agent Sitwell is for sure evil?? BOOO. I kept thinking he was going to be one of Fury's double double double however many times agents inside of Hydra.

And I am deeply unsure about what they are doing to Natasha's backstory! Are they really taking out the whole super soldier/Red Room/etc. stuff?! Because WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?!?!?! MARVEL YOU SHOULD MAKE A BLACK WIDOW MOVIE LIKE TWO YEARS AGO. Anyway, I will now hope that they'll cover some of that in CA3, which will obviously be about Bucky. And either Natasha is really really really covering up and not telling Steve stuff, or she has repressed Red Room memories, which is a more probable fanwank.

There also seemed to be a much higher body count than usual, possibly because we were inside SHIELD and therefore not killing civilians? I liked the small touch of people helping each other out of the tipped over Metro car before Hydra starts shooting it up to get to Steve, and although it was a bit cheesy, I did like how Steve's speech echoed what he says in Avengers to Loki in Germany and how the wee engineer guy saying no to scary Hydra dude paralleled the old German guy in Avengers standing up to Loki. And I really like that it did take him a while to screw up his courage, because making choices like that is hard, and I like it when things point out that doing the right thing is not the easy way at times. (Also, I always wonder what I would do in a situation like that. Because I would like to be brave, but I also know I would be terrified, as I generally like my brains inside my head.)

Come to think of it, aside from the intrigue, much of the plot really was like Avengers, only with Hydra instead of Loki deciding that the only way you can have peace and order is to kill a ton of people. I also very much liked how much of an ensemble it felt like; I honestly hadn't expected that much for Falcon to do, especially given all the other established characters floating around in there, and I really loved Sam and Steve's growing friendship.

Also: WINGS!!!! I was super happy the audience cheered a lot for him.

(One does wonder where Hawkeye was in all this though.)

They allllmooost had me believing that Fury was dead, because part of my thinking he wasn't was him showing up in trailers all wounded, and I didn't realize all that had taken place BEFORE his car got blown up! (Also, he has the same phone as my BiL, haha!) But given that Pierce was the villain and you clearly needed some sort of resistance, I mostly figured otherwise. Also, even if he was dead in the movie, people obviously don't stay dead long in the MCU.

Poor Agent 13 really doesn't get much to do. And was she on the phone with Peggy when we first see her?

YAY Steve and Peggy scene! It made me tear up.

I also would have watched an entire movie's worth of the Steve-and-Natasha roadtrip. Love all the interaction, and possibly ship them a LOT now. Or, er, a lot more than before, which was already a fair amount? I feel they had to stick all the stuff about setting him up with various women to dampen the prospects of an Avengers couple. Also, movie, I was fully expecting Steve to have to put his life in Natasha's hands at some point on trust given their give and take at Sam's place! She got some really cool action sequences, but I would have liked less of Steve shielding her a ton and the being wounded and unconscious at various points.

Love the entire sequence of her as the World Security Council woman kicking everyone's ass, although I was a bit sad to see it was Natasha and not an older woman being an action hero, because that would have been really awesome.

And oh Steve, you do always go down with the ship, don't you? The scene where he just lets Bucky punch him and doesn't try to fight back because he's with Bucky till the end ... much better than the Cosmic Cube! (Though possibly in the comic he just lets Bucky whale on him too?) But OMG I am such a sucker for scenes like that and the slow realization of "Maybe I know you enough to drag you out of the water but I have to go away and angst before we have more of a reunion."

Also, I very much appreciated Steve's tight t-shirt in the opening scenes. Natasha got more clingy clothes than she had in Avengers (also WHY the zipper down on her bodysuit in the helicopter? It was 5 seconds, you guys could have just had it up!)

Love that Steve steals his old costume and that that's what he's wearing in the final showdown with Bucky, because of course he is.

Actually, I love all the moments of Steve's past coming back, because of course it does for the Winter Soldier, from the Smithsonian exhibit to the visit with Peggy to his old uniform to his old training camp. And the moment when he's facing down Bucky on the bridge of one of the Helicarriers and how it echoes the moment he faces down Red Skull across the bridge in CA1 and then has to leap over to where Bucky is.

I am not sure how I feel about the dismantling of SHIELD. Because on the one hand, yes, I like that Maria Hill and Natasha both agree that it has to happen and it's not just a "the weaponized Helicarriers and all that research from the cosmic cube will be totally fine!! As long as it's SHIELD and not Hydra!" thing, and it's that the entire organization can be suspect, even the non-Hydra bits. On the other hand... what are they going to do?! Ahahaha, are they going to have to change the name of the TV show?

I do kinda love the idea of Maria Hill and Pepper working together though.

On that note, I think the movie baaaarely passes the Bechdel test, and at least this time Maria and Natasha actually talk to each other? But not a lot!

Eeee, Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch! (She really does look like another one of Joss' dangerous waifish brunettes, doesn't she?)

(Also was Abed a SHIELD agent?)

Going back to the ending with Natasha, which also totally echoes the ending of the Avengers with Fury telling off the World Security Council (or whatever they are called), I don't know if that heralds the re-formation of SHIELD? Both their speeches are a bit too much Dark Knight-esque in the whole "you need us superpowered beings who can come in and ignore all the rules and do what really must be done," though that's hardly the sole purview of the Nolan movies (see: Iron Man).

I will now just pretend she said that to get people off her back, and she's also on her own stealth mission to Russia since after digging up files for Steve, she got bits of memory back as well. Ready for fic now!

(no subject)

Sat, Apr. 5th, 2014 02:26 am (UTC)
princessofgeeks: (Default)
Posted by [personal profile] princessofgeeks
Yeah, I can't wait for the fic.

Also I think Pepper and Maria could totally rule the world.

Thank you for the post.

(no subject)

Sat, Apr. 5th, 2014 05:09 pm (UTC)
jadelennox: Black Widow in the style of Sendak, holding a "Shield!" flag (avengers: sendak black widow)
Posted by [personal profile] jadelennox
There was a brief Bechdel pass when Maria shows up, yeah.

And yeah, this Wanda looks like a victimised joss waif, but I'm hoping; he did such a good job with Natasha.

I loved that this was an ensemble piece that gave respect to Sam's and Nick's and Natasha's arcs and motiviations as well as to Steve's.

(no subject)

Sun, Apr. 6th, 2014 06:43 am (UTC)
nettlecoats: when you gotta compliment a guy on his sweet muscular thighs (morning bells)
Posted by [personal profile] nettlecoats
Sorry, lurker delurking to say: ABED! YESSSSSSS!!!

My sister pointed out to me that Natasha is wearing a necklace with a tiny arrow on it in a few scenes, so... that's Hawkeye's cameo for this movie, I guess?

I found the Steve and Peggy scene maybe the most affecting bit. Especially since I was frustrated this meetup never happened in Brubaker's run on Cap. (C-can I ask, are you reading the comics? Or maybe just following the general developments? The latter is pretty much my policy when it comes to, oh, Spider-Man, for example - I'm sort of interested, but not enough to track down the source material.)

ETA: I definitely don't mean for that question to sound like an implicit endorsement of the comics along the lines of "everyone should be reading them" because noooooo, very much the opposite. I have a lot of opinions about the comics and a good many of them are complaints.
Edited Sun, Apr. 6th, 2014 08:31 pm (UTC)

(no subject)

Wed, Apr. 9th, 2014 06:04 am (UTC)
nettlecoats: where the nettles grow (the farthest shore)
Posted by [personal profile] nettlecoats
she wore something like that in Avengers too, right?

Yeeeees? Now that I go and check, she's wearing what looks like a stylized spider necklace in her first scene with Bruce. (Uh, funny story: I was totally unfamiliar with these characters when I first saw the Avengers movie and missed every internal reference to everything ever.)

IIRC Natasha makes appearances in several of the arcs after Death of Captain America for the time Bucky has the title, but she's mostly there as backup/supportive girlfriend/driving the getaway car. She does team up with Sharon at one point while Bucky's otherwise occupied, that was kind of fun to see. Overall there was less backstory stuff in the Captain America run proper than I was expecting: very little for Bucky and Natasha, a bit more for Bucky and Steve. One of the issues of Brubaker's Captain America & Bucky has extended Natasha and Bucky flashback. Maybe there's more in the actual Winter Soldier series? Haven't read that one yet.

I like that Natasha gets to do some angsting herself later in the Avengers Assemble series - for example, the Age of Ultron AU issue where she takes a day off and it does not go well (UNDERSTATEMENT). Otherwise I'm not comics savvy enough to know where to find quality Natasha stories, sadness.

I've been keeping a mental list of authors I mostly trust not to make me angry and artists I mostly trust not to surprise me with gratuitously perky nipples. ;P

(no subject)

Mon, Apr. 7th, 2014 07:08 am (UTC)
starlady: The Avengers regroup in Midtown (Natasha, Steve, Clint, Thor) (more legendary and more desperate)
Posted by [personal profile] starlady
Yeah, I ship it. A lot.

I agree with you about Hydra vs SHIELD, etc. The movie comes as close as it can, I guess? And I think, given that several characters hammer the "Hydra = SHIELD" thing at a couple points, that's definitely farther than I was expecting.

It was very satisfying, but definitely somewhat Bucky-lite given that the movie was named after him!

The ending is also something of a callback to the end of IM1, isn't it? Honesty is the best policy.

(no subject)

Fri, Apr. 11th, 2014 03:52 pm (UTC)
troisroyaumes: Painting of a duck, with the hanzi for "summer" in the top left (Default)
Posted by [personal profile] troisroyaumes
Haven't watched the movie but I've spent the morning procrastinating by reading everyone's reactions to it! (Am thoroughly spoiled as a result, but realistically, I probably would not have gotten around to seeing this in theaters anyway.)

how the movies keep alllmooooost getting into how SHIELD and SHIELD's methods really aren't the best way to operate, but then swerve away at the last minute by creating an even more evil organization and thus validating our heroes in the end

You know, I've been reading various thoughtful posts discussing this issue--is the film's message really a critique of the current America? And if so, does that critique go far enough? The discussion keeps rotating around: "Is the movie saying that the evil is endemic to SHIELD or brought in by HYDRA?" To me, the fact that this is the question is pretty telling and already a sign that the movie has failed to really make the critique (for me anyway). Because historically, of course, Nazism was in no small way influenced by the homegrown U.S. eugenics movement in the 1920s and 1930s; the ideas behind Nazism were never "from the outside" to begin with. So the ground was right there for the movie to not only say HYDRA was in SHIELD from the beginning but also that the causation is circular: Americanism, to a certain extent, was responsible for creating HYDRA in the first place. It's probably expecting way too much for a mainstream blockbuster comic book movie to go that far, of course...

Anyway, just a random thought I had!

(no subject)

Sat, May. 2nd, 2015 06:36 am (UTC)
Posted by (Anonymous)
I need to watch this movie again! Preferably in 2D. Winter Soldier is just awesome, too much awesomeness by Sebastian Stan.


oyceter: teruterubouzu default icon (Default)

April 2017


Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags