oyceter: man*ga [mahng' guh] n. Japanese comics. synonym: CRACK (manga is crack)
[personal profile] oyceter
I am so confused! Again! I did not even realize that there was yet another Sakura until I read Mely and Rilina's posts!

Mostly I am concerned for Yuuko! Aiiieee! She was hurt! And apparently rendered ineffectual?

And Fai hit Kurogane! I can hear all the slashers squeeing.

But mostly I am freaked out by the melting people, as it recalls a truly surreal and horrifying GI Joe episode from my youth, in which someone's family was taken over by papier-mache clone-people who also melted like that.

Someone explain what's going on with the different Syaorans and Sakuras?

Please no spoilers for xxxHolic unless it's under <span style="color:#333;background-color:#333">spoiler code</span>.

(no subject)

Thu, Apr. 24th, 2008 01:54 am (UTC)
ext_12920: (group hug)
Posted by [identity profile] desdenova.livejournal.com
Yuko: Ack! It never even occurred to me that she might be in danger! 'Cause she's Yuko! She's too awesome to die! Right...?

Fai/Kurogane: I myself really liked the part where Fai's all, "Yes, I learned the error or my ways. Don't go adopting my bad habits." (Although...hitting people? Maybe Fai is the one adopting Kuro-tan's bad habits?)

Melting people: I don't think I ever say that GI Joe episode, but it was still disturbing to me! In fact, even though I read it weeks ago, I'm still disturbed!

Multiple Syaorans and Sakuras:

If I've counted right, there are (in Tsubasa & xxxHolic) three known versions of Sakura, and 2-3 versions of Syaoran (depending on how you count.

Syaoran: There's Original!Syaoran, who was in the tank for a long, long time. There's UnSyaoran, the soulless drone created by Fei Wang, and who ATE FAI'S EYE. And there is Clow!Syaoran (for want of a better term), who was the result of Original!Syaoran putting half his soul into UnSyaoran's body. That's three personalities with two bodies. (I can't believe I am even trying to think this through rationally! Oh, manga.)

Sakura: There's Clow!Sakura, who appeared in the first chapter, then got switched out with Clone!Sakura by Fei Wang (and whose body was destroyed). Clone!Sakura is the one who went on the quest, and who paid the price of her memories of Syaoran to Yuko. Her soul was split from her body at the end of the Gothic Bondage Battle Chess arc, and was (I think?) destroyed by UnSyaoran during the fight in the dreamworld with Real!Syaoran. Now, we also apparently have an Original!Sakura to go with Original!Syaoran. We don't know anything about her except that Original!Syaoran knew her before he went in the tube.

Do I have all that right???

Personally, I think that the Syaoran & Sakura from the very beginning of the manga, in the glass tube, are Original!Syaoran and Original!Sakura. I am very interested to find out what the connection between Original!Sakura and Clow!Sakura is. I suspect it's not just a matter of alternate-universe versions.

As to what is *really* going on, I have no idea, except that Clow Reed is definitely behind a large part of it. A lot of the things Yuko has said over the course of both Tsubasa & xxxHolic make me think that a lot of what's happening is due to an elaborate plan set in motion by Clow & Yuko--possibly to counter Fei Wang's own long game.

Speaking of Clow Reed, is Tsubasa!Clow the same Clow Reed as in Card Captor Sakura, or is he an alternate-universe version?

I agree it's all very confusing.

Sorry for babbling on so long in your comments; I got carried away...

(no subject)

Thu, Apr. 24th, 2008 12:32 pm (UTC)
ext_12920: (trc: fai bw)
Posted by [identity profile] desdenova.livejournal.com
Clow!Syaoran: Yes, I think he is gone for good. But who knows, with this manga?

Original!Sakura: I think you will get your wish soon! Fortunately it's a weekly manga, so there's no waiting for a month between chapters.

Death-Note: Hah! I would totally read the Death-Note version of Tsubasa, consisting of Yuko, Fei Wang, and Clow sitting around explaining their stragems, interspersed with brief bits of action.

(no subject)

Fri, Apr. 25th, 2008 01:42 am (UTC)
ext_12920: (manga)
Posted by [identity profile] desdenova.livejournal.com
You have better self-restraint than me! I definitely prefer reading in big chunks. And not on a screen. But the lure of What Happens Next is too great for me. (I mean, I never intended to go the scans route on these series, I just stumbled across them, and read over a year's worth of chapters in a weekend! I am hopeless.)

(no subject)

Thu, Apr. 24th, 2008 08:18 am (UTC)
Posted by [identity profile] rilina.livejournal.com
I officially have no idea what is going on with Syaoran and Sakura.

Profile

oyceter: teruterubouzu default icon (Default)
Oyceter

March 2021

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910 111213
1415 1617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags