Ogawa Yayoi - Tramps Like Us, vol. 13-14 (Eng. trans.)
Wed, Feb. 13th, 2008 05:48 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
oyceterSo, I read vol. 13 a few months ago and have unsurprisingly forgotten everything that happened in it. This made reading vol. 14 very odd, as vol. 14 reads more like an epilogue and less like a conclusion.
Quickly re-skimming vol. 13 makes things make more sense...
I really love that volume 13 spends so much time on Sumire's career and career decisions; on the other hand, I'm still sad she decides to quit. But! She gets offers to freelance, which is cool!
Er, am not deriding anyone who decides to quit. It's just that in these narratives, it feels like even when the decision is given page time and thoughtfulness, the women tend to quit (just like how most women in movies decide to not get an abortion).
I would also growl at the baby thing, except it leads up to the cuteness of Sumire's kid and Yuri's kid growing up together. I liked that there was an entire chapter spent on their friendship and how Yuri would miss her when she moved.
I don't know. I feel like I should say more, except I wanted a more unconventional ending, even though I was 90% sure I wasn't going to get it. I miss the Momo-Sumire pet dynamic, and while I'm glad Momo has grown up, there wasn't enough of their now-romantic relationship to capture the same delicate oddness of their previous relationship. It may have worked better for me had it had more page time, and of course, I'm more interested in seeing how things play out long-term, after the first blush has faded.
In conclusion: though I like this series, I don't quite love it, and the same applies to the ending. I love that it addresses a lot of issues most series don't, but this is also its drawback, as I keep wanting it to go farther than it does, and it's frustrating seeing that.
Quickly re-skimming vol. 13 makes things make more sense...
I really love that volume 13 spends so much time on Sumire's career and career decisions; on the other hand, I'm still sad she decides to quit. But! She gets offers to freelance, which is cool!
Er, am not deriding anyone who decides to quit. It's just that in these narratives, it feels like even when the decision is given page time and thoughtfulness, the women tend to quit (just like how most women in movies decide to not get an abortion).
I would also growl at the baby thing, except it leads up to the cuteness of Sumire's kid and Yuri's kid growing up together. I liked that there was an entire chapter spent on their friendship and how Yuri would miss her when she moved.
I don't know. I feel like I should say more, except I wanted a more unconventional ending, even though I was 90% sure I wasn't going to get it. I miss the Momo-Sumire pet dynamic, and while I'm glad Momo has grown up, there wasn't enough of their now-romantic relationship to capture the same delicate oddness of their previous relationship. It may have worked better for me had it had more page time, and of course, I'm more interested in seeing how things play out long-term, after the first blush has faded.
In conclusion: though I like this series, I don't quite love it, and the same applies to the ending. I love that it addresses a lot of issues most series don't, but this is also its drawback, as I keep wanting it to go farther than it does, and it's frustrating seeing that.
(no subject)
Sun, Feb. 17th, 2008 03:18 am (UTC)(no subject)
Tue, Feb. 19th, 2008 09:04 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Thu, Feb. 21st, 2008 04:19 am (UTC)(no subject)
Sat, Feb. 23rd, 2008 01:11 am (UTC)