oyceter: Stack of books with text "mmm... books!" (mmm books)
Oyceter ([personal profile] oyceter) wrote2005-12-01 12:41 am

Zimmermann, Elizabeth - Knitting Without Tears

(subtitle: Basic Techniques and Easy-to-Follow Directions for Garments to Fit All Sizes)

I wanted a book on knitting techniques instead of just going through the various stitches and cast-ons and ways to bind off and etc. I've got another book on sweater design, and I was bored to death during it -- I don't think about these things, and I don't really want to design sweaters. This book is somewhat the same. I feel like the advice would probably be horribly good if I would, say, actually listen to it.

Unfortunately, I knit sort of like I do everything else -- haphazardly, randomly, with much improvisation and really no clue at all what I'm doing. I seem to be really bad at following rules, largely because I will inevitably be lacking a specific piece of equipment, ingredient, yarn, needle size, whatever. I really wanted this book to be like my ideal cookbook, i.e. something I could flip through and get really cool tips and shortcuts from.

Also, while Zimmermann is supposedly (to continue my knitting-to-cooking comparision) like the Julia Child of the knitting world, I don't actually find her to be all that accessible. She reads as very opinionated, which, understandably, she says she is. Alas, I am not the kind of knitter who likes people with strong opinions tinkering around in my knitting and telling me that I really should be gauging and swatching and whatnot. I do know that I should be gauging, but honestly, I'm too lazy. I don't gauge. I just sort of start out on the piece, whip out a tape measure a little later, and see if it's around what the pattern says. If it isn't, I'd honestly rather recalculate the pattern than re-cast-on on different sized needles.

Plus, things just happen!

I am being unfairly cranky with Zimmermann; my general impression is that she is very opinionated on how she likes to knit, but she does indeed encourage readers to knit however they like. She just sounds so authoritative that it turns me off.

But yes, I suppose I wanted something with more nifty tips and tricks, like... if you suddenly have a burning desire to start on a pattern that requires stitch holders and you have none, cut up twist ties into little segments and use those. Or... If you suddenly have the burning desire to start on your new scarf with cables and have no cable needle, just use a random needle out of your interchangeable knitting needle set! Erm, yes, this is stuff I do, and as a result, my knitting looks very ghetto. But I care not! I get my results anyway.

Anyway, I think the Yarn Harlot's At Knit's End will probably appeal to me more.

[identity profile] harriet-spy.livejournal.com 2005-12-01 12:57 am (UTC)(link)
You have to understand Zimmerman in context. If you look at knitting books of her time, you see that most of them emphasize blind following of pattern, to the point that you weren't even supposed to read ahead in the pattern beyond the line you were executing (!!!). So her books are basically about not being a knitting zombie.

I'm not very good at following rules exactly myself; that's why I'm a knitter and not a sewer. However, I think with a little experience you will find out exactly why gauge swatches are (usually) good time-saving devices, especially if you substitute yarns. I just had to redo about eight rows of knitting on a hat because the yarn and needle combination was not producing the fabric I wanted.

[identity profile] harriet-spy.livejournal.com 2005-12-01 10:15 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't know if anyone's written a book on this yet, but they probably should: in both cooking and knitting, you can see a line from domestic arts assumed to be taught at home, with commercial patterns/recipes that are very general and assume an ability to (or even a need to) work out the details for oneself (*), in the early part of the twentieth century, to post-WWII patterns/recipes that assume less knowledge, present a very narrowly-conceived, conformist ideal and infantilize their female audience (as well as being very U.S.-culture insular), to the 60s/70s explosion of individuality and doing your own thing, to the present day with its focus on multiculturalism or discovering your own heritage. I think you can recover a lot about norms of femininity looking at pattern- and cookbooks.


* I used to have a site called Historical Knitting Patterns with patterns I transcribed while procrastinating in research libraries. The patterns tend to be very unspecific ("decrease until the sleeve is the desired width," that sort of thing) and there's much less emphasis on fashionability.

[identity profile] chi-zu.livejournal.com 2005-12-01 04:08 am (UTC)(link)
I love At Knit's End though it is more pithy bromides than knitting manual.

I think you should check out Teva Durham's Loop-d-Loop. She has a very experimental knitting style and an almost sculptural fine art approach. Even if you don't like her aesthetic it's a fascinating book because she writes about her knitting philosophies.

There's another knitter out there who does CRAZY stuff. I can never remember her name though. But I've always wanted to read her book. From the sound of it she's practically reinventing knitting in bizarre and unusual ways. I've seen one of her patterns for a pair of socks where she had to make up her own pattern notation because regular charts were inadequate to express the complexities of what she was doing. Ah! Here she is: Debbie New author of Unexpected Knitting (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0942018222/qid=1133438462/sr=2-1/ref=pd_bbs_b_2_1/104-9396503-4976754?s=books&v=glance&n=283155).

I enjoy reading EZ for her andecdotes and her obvious fondness for the craft. I pick up interesting tidbits from her as well. I don't really knit the way she does, nor do I share her style, but I like the way she writes about knitting. It's kind of like the knitting version of The Yankee New England Cookbook.

Another person you might want to check out if you haven't already is Barbara Walker. I adore Knitting From the Top which is a sweater design book of sorts, but it's written rather conversationally and has a great list of random knitterly tricks in the back. She also has published what is basically THE stitch library in four volumes.

[identity profile] chi-zu.livejournal.com 2005-12-01 06:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Well no one says you HAVE to like EZ. ^_^ I don't always.

But do check out the others, they're zany!

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-01 06:29 pm (UTC)(link)
I'm tempted to splurge on knitting software, so I can avoid all the math needed for fitting things. Right now? I just go by chest measurement, and eyeball the length. Eventually I'll be a good girl and use the instructions for proper fitting that's posted over on knitty.

I hate the idea of wasting perfectly good yarn, so I don't bother cutting the yarn when I'm checking my guage. Yeeeeeah, it means I won't have a swatch for future reference, but it's really not that difficult to write down "Yarn XYZ, dk weight, 5.5 stitches on size 7 needle" in a notebook.

Incidentally, I really lucked out the last time I didn't bother checking guage. I was making Tempting a size bigger than I should have... but it turned out that I knit very, very tightly... so it ended up fitting perfect. Hee!

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-02 05:44 pm (UTC)(link)
Sweater Wizard (http://www.software4knitting.com/) is the only one that I'm aware of. It's $90--perhaps we could go half-sies on it? One of us can hold on to the original and the other can hold on to the, uh, archival copy for, erm, safe keeping? ;)

I'm a slow knitter, so when it takes me a couple of months to knit one sweater, I want it for ME, dammit!

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-03 06:57 am (UTC)(link)
Oooooh! knitpicks has it for $70! Even better :) Hmm... do you know where one can find promotion/coupon codes for knitpicks? I know you can enter one on the order page!

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-03 08:47 am (UTC)(link)
Go download the demo. It doesn't have as much functionality as the full version, but I was able to play around with all the shaping options (it's automatically set to a 30 inch chest, but you can manually change the schematic! So really, all you need to know is what kind of ease you want). And the user manual is available on the product website in pdf form, so it doesn't matter that there's no help file. You also can't export as a Word document (which would be nice if you want to add a stitch pattern), but you CAN print. I'm sure that there are other options that we're not seeing, but for my needs (and budget!) the free demo seems like a good bet. And you don't have to register, so no spam for trying :)

So I guess I'll move the needlemaster back to the top spot on my channukah wish list.

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-08 02:53 am (UTC)(link)
I've heard that the Denise kit is made a bit better than the needlemaster, so I think I'm going to get that. I'm a tight knitter, so I don't really need tiny needles.

I think if you put in "socks" you can get free shipping on orders under $30.

As far as software goes... it seems that they forgot to disable the save/print feature on the demo... so I'm getting it to do everything that I want.

[identity profile] knullabulla.livejournal.com 2005-12-02 06:17 pm (UTC)(link)
oops, there's also Knitware Sweater Design (http://www.islandnet.com/knitware/swdesc.htm) for about $50. They've both got demos available, so I'm going to test them out whenever I've got the time.