oyceter: Stack of books with text "mmm... books!" (mmm books)
Oyceter ([personal profile] oyceter) wrote2015-08-20 12:38 am

Lerner, Rose - multiple books

I've been hearing about Rose Lerner for a while, but I didn't particularly enjoy the first book of hers that I read (A Lily Among Thorns), so I didn't try any of her others until now. (I have been marathoning Parks and Recreation and wanted something that felt like the main romance in the show, and suddenly remembered Lerner!)

Her specialties so far seem to be: nice people who genuinely like each other, heroes who are decidedly not jerks, class issues, local life and politics, sibling dynamics, the weight of parental expectations, and protagonists who have a very difficult time knowing and/or expressing what they want because they have sublimated their desires, frequently out of the desire to be nice and get along with society. And the last bit seems very evenly split between the men and the women, which I very much appreciated.

So far, there has been more diversity around the protagonists rather than embodied by the protagonists, but like Courtney Milan, my sense is that she is pushing at a lot of those boundaries. There are secondary characters who are POC and gay and lesbian—I am using these terms as a shortcut, since they don't quite match up with Regency categories/ways of thinking—and her latest hero is Jewish! And it looks like the protagonists of her next book are in the servant class, which is nice.

In for a Penny - Lord Nevinstoke's father dies, leaving his family deep in debt, and thus Nev proposes to Penelope Brown, who comes with a substantial dowry courtesy of her father's success in trade. Together, they attempt to restore his family estate and prevent a peasant uprising! The couple is probably the most traditional in terms of romance norms, and I find them absolutely adorable. It also helps that "socially inept heroine who is good at spreadsheets + hero who is not the best with numbers but great with people" is something that hits rather close to home. The book tends to fall a bit into the "wealthy titled people rescue impoverished workers" thing, and the villain and final conflict feels over-the-top compared to the rest of the story, but I liked it a lot.

A Lily Among Thorns - I bounced off this one the first time because I wanted an icier heroine, but on rereading it and knowing better what to expect, I liked it better. Lady Serena, former courtesan and current innkeeper, wants to help Solomon Hathaway find heirloom earrings, as he's the one who gave her the money to buy herself out years and years ago. And then there are French spies and threats from Serena's father and the plot is a bit over the top still. Solomon the tailor (or rather, master dyer) is very cute, but I didn't fully buy that Serena was able to terrorize the London underworld. Good, but I think it's the weakest of Lerner's work.

Sweet Disorder - Nick Dymond goes to the town of Lively St. Lemeston, where his brother is running for office, in order to convince widow Phoebe Sparks to marry a Whig so that her husband gets her inherited vote. I love that Phoebe is middle class and worries about having to wear the same dress to parties and can't afford mustard. Also, she is fat and the narrative is fine with it, and the hero needs a cane due to wartime injuries. I think this is my favorite of Lerner's books so far, and I particularly love one sex scene that manages to be hot while also advancing characterization AND tying up the hero. Bonus points for many loving descriptions of Regency era sweets.

True Pretenses - Ash and his little brother Rafe are con men, but Rafe wants to get out, so Ash comes up with one last con to get Rafe married to an heiress so she can get her money and Rafe can get money for a commission. Despite his secret hopes that Rafe and Lydia (aforementioned heiress) will fall in love, Ash somehow ends up engaged to her himself. They bond over the difficulty of raising younger siblings while also wanting to give them everything and how conning people and being a gentlewoman call on a similar set of skills. I especially like how being Jewish is integral to the characterization of both Ash and Rafe. On the other hand, I didn't like this as much as I had anticipated because both Ash and Lydia are rather overbearing older siblings and I ended up sympathizing with Rafe a lot. That and I wasn't entirely confident about the happily ever after, not because I didn't like the characters together, but because I still stressed about how Ash's past could still be dug up. Still, I think this is probably Lerner's best and chewiest book to date. Also, I love that Lydia is a Tory while the main characters in the previous book are Whigs and that she doesn't get converted and still doesn't like them.
coffeeandink: (Default)

[personal profile] coffeeandink 2015-08-20 12:04 pm (UTC)(link)
Yay Rose Lerner and yay Parks and Rec!

I feel like True Pretenses SHOULD be my favorite, but my favorite is Sweet Disorder anyway. Maybe I will try rereading A Lily Among Thorns with adjusted expectations, but only half the problem was Serena not being icy enough. The other half was that I kept expecting Solomon and his family to be Jewish, and then they weren't.

Lerner also reminds me a little bit of early Carla Kelly, in that so many of her characters are doing their best to be kind to each other. Maybe that is particularly In for a Penny. Her characterization is more nuanced and varied than Kelly's, though; for example, I suspect all Kelly protagonists would like each other. I especially like the thing where Lydia and Phoebe don't like each other. The warm fuzzy glow of infinite amity among all the romance heroes and heroines in a series annoys and bores me.

Did you read the vampire/dragon Nick/Phoebe AU Lerner wrote on her blog? It's so cute! I want the entire book!
skygiants: the aunts from Pushing Daisies reading and sipping wine on a couch (wine and books)

[personal profile] skygiants 2015-08-20 12:16 pm (UTC)(link)
It's OK, you guys can like Sweet Disorder best, I love True Pretenses enough for EVERYBODY.
skygiants: Izumi and Sig Curtis from Fullmetal Alchemist embracing in front of a giant heart (curtises!)

[personal profile] skygiants 2015-08-20 12:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Lydia doesn't like basically ANYONE from the last book! I loved it so much! And that Lerner is willing to make Lydia likable for all the reasons it is possible to be likeable for being a Tory, despite the fact that I suspect her convictions and the convictions of most of her readers (including me!) lean wildly the other way.

(It all DOES seem very Parks and Rec.)
oracne: turtle (Default)

[personal profile] oracne 2015-08-20 12:54 pm (UTC)(link)
I read TRUE PRETENSES and that was enough to make me buy SWEET DISORDER even though it is still on the TBR like everything else.
heresluck: (book)

[personal profile] heresluck 2015-08-20 02:38 pm (UTC)(link)
Ooh, these sound fun! I haven't been in the mood to read romance for ages (...I think the 'ships on my TV shows have been wearing me out), but this post may change that.
coffeeandink: (Default)

[personal profile] coffeeandink 2015-08-20 03:27 pm (UTC)(link)
I think you would like these.
heresluck: (book)

[personal profile] heresluck 2015-08-21 02:17 pm (UTC)(link)
I trust both you and Oyce about these things!
heresluck: (book)

[personal profile] heresluck 2015-08-21 02:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, these are the elements that really appeal. So many romances -- even ones I like and have kept for comfort re-reading -- feel pretty interchangeable. My very favorite romances are the ones that feel distinct and specific, and while local politics isn't the only way to do that, it's actually more to my personal taste than the over-the-top cracktasticness that some authors use to get there. (Though god knows I have read my fair share of over-the-top cracktasticness! Heh.)
lnhammer: Yotsuba Koiwai running - caption: "Enjoy Everything" (enjoy everything)

[personal profile] lnhammer 2015-08-20 07:46 pm (UTC)(link)
Sounds like I want to try either Sweet Disorder or In for a Penny first.

lnhammer: lo-fi photo of a tall, thin man - caption: "some guy" (Default)

[personal profile] lnhammer 2015-08-21 03:09 pm (UTC)(link)
Either would work, depending on my mood. Right now, Penny sounds better, but by the time I get through my current in-progress, who knows ...

rilina: (Default)

[personal profile] rilina 2015-08-21 02:15 am (UTC)(link)
Ooh, titles to investigate. Your post reminds me that I am pretty sure I saw Lerner recced on the RNFF blog and never did follow up..
bibliofile: Fan & papers in a stack (from my own photo) (Default)

[personal profile] bibliofile 2015-08-22 09:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Oooh, people who are NICE to each other? I'm so tired of characters who are nasty and unkind; sometimes one's escapism really does need better people. Will investigate one or more of these books soon.